Smith, Herbst, Fullam re-elected to Vandalia-Butler school board

Voting was underway at Redman's Picnic Grounds in Troy on Tuesday, Nov. 4, 2025. BRYANT BILLING / STAFF

Voting was underway at Redman's Picnic Grounds in Troy on Tuesday, Nov. 4, 2025. BRYANT BILLING / STAFF

Incumbent candidates Mary Kay Smith, Holly Herbst, and Scott Fullam have been re-elected to the Vandalia-Butler school board, according to final, unofficial results from the Montgomery County Board of Elections.

Results show 27.42% of votes were cast for Smith, 27.89% for Herbst, 24.62% for Fullam, and 20.07% for candidate Ryan Chewning.

Results will be certified by the board of elections on Nov. 19.

In responses to a recent Dayton Daily News questionnaire, the four candidates shared their reasons for running.

Chewning said he’d joined the race to bring a fresh perspective, with a goal to better represent district parents and promote better community engagement.

Herbst said she ran for re-election to continue to ensure every student has access to a high-quality education in a safe and supportive environment.

Smith said she wants to continue serving on the board because she believes public schools are vital to strengthening communities by providing equal access to education and programs despite differences in socio-economic backgrounds.

Fullam said he sought re-election to continue the forward momentum the district has experienced over his time on the board.

About the Author